Referee's Report - Observing Project #1

You will each be given top referee a group report from the first observing project. Your principal job is to report back to me (the editor) whether and how the report meets the criteria and objectives spelled out in the assignment. Your remarks are advisory to me, the editor. I then advise the authors how to revise their manuscript.

Please submit your comments to me (one-page max). I will forward them to the authors unless I deem them inappropriate. You should not feel obligated to rewrite their paper, but if you do have constructive comments you can attach them to your report or return the marked up paper to me.